Categorized | Security

Like Francisco Franco, Internet Kill Switch is Still Dead

kill switchSometimes a really bad idea can live on, no matter how thoroughly it’s rejected. Such is the case with the “Internet kill switch” idea featured on and off in proposed homeland security legislation.

The notion is that the President, or in some versions some other government agency, should have the power to disconnect certain “critical infrastructure” in the event of an emergency which meets legislative criteria. We’ll ignore the fact that attacks against such infrastructure could be executed in microseconds, far too quickly for government to react. And any pre-emptive action would inevitably cause huge economic losses; imagine the major banks being taken offline for…how long?

The idea has been floating out there for a few years and became prominent early in the Obama administration. An eclectic and seemingly centrist group of legislators, including Senators Collins from Maine and Lieberman from Connecticut, advocated it. But even putting aside considerable technical and logistical problems with the proposal, the interests against it are huge. It never had a chance.

But now that Egypt has shown that it can shut itself off from the Internet altogether, Senator Collins has been inspired to reintroduce her bill which expired with the last congress. Why now? Fortunately, all the reasons why it was a bad idea before are still operative and the interests against it are at least as well organized.



Full story: Security Watch

Related Posts

Comments are closed.

Security Status

Beware Facebook "Timeline" scams http://t.co/W5EW0cVv
5 months ago
Nigerian government (unknowingly) hosts phishing website http://t.co/uQd42ENw
5 months ago
PCMag Awards McAfee All Access its Editors’ Choice: SANTA CLARA, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--McAfee today announced... http://t.co/FakV7Vd8
5 months ago
RT @mikko: I hadn't noticed Google Maps has added 3D models of buildings. Here's a (very accurate) view of F-Secure HQ in Helsinki http://t.co/IKfAZlak
5 months ago
North Koreans aren't known for their online presence. But others may be lured into clicking Kim Jong-Il 'videos' too http://t.co/yQOon6YT
5 months ago
How to Protect Your Professional Reputation on Facebook Timeline http://t.co/I4bcR2VN
5 months ago
This is pretty impressive from @Softpedia: Facebook scans 2 trillion link clicks and blocks 220 million posts each day http://t.co/vKsn9gNl
5 months ago
Need for integrated approach to security in industrial control systems - http://t.co/tPBCNOow with @PikeResearch
5 months ago
Some free-based music we play at work http://t.co/xu5agZfc
5 months ago
Japan’s cyber defense weapon: a virus. It includes quotes by @Luis_Corrons via @InfosecurityMag
5 months ago